Abby Goodnough looks at how the Isabella Gardner Museum is trying to overcome the legacy of Gardner's restrictive will and the devastating unsolved theft.
Now, in a victory the Gardner had been awaiting for months, the Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts ruled on March 4 that the museum can depart from the strict parameters of Gardner’s prickly will. It called the expansion a “reasonable deviation” from the will because it is in the public interest to protect the building from overuse.
According to the will if the arrangement of any of the museum’s holdings changes, the entire collection, the building and the land beneath it must be turned over to Harvard.
Goodnough's article presents a museum that seems to labor under the legacy of a Jamesian secret history. Although the thefts are a subject of recurring interest they seem to have infused the museum with melancholy in this presentation.
It does seem too bad that very particular and eccentric museums like this have to be improved with the worst example being the plan to move the Barnes Collection. That said, the Gardner's plans to expand and bring in new blood come across as a form of exorcism here.
